In The News
Explore SAIS
In The News
Explore SAIS

The B.I.P.R. site uses cookies and similar technologies.
By clicking the "Accept" button, or continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, including our cookie policy.


BIPR | Withdrawal from Afghanistan: Causes and Consequences
Withdrawal from Afghanistan: Causes and Consequences

November 8, 2021 - 18:30

Albert Gerard (Bert) Koenders, Former Minister of Foreign Affairs and Special Envoy of the Worldbank on Fragility, The Netherlands

Event Recap

A SAIS alumnus and former visiting professor, Bert Koenders makes his return to the Bologna campus to answer questions from both the chair, Professor Michael Leigh, and a panel of students on the US withdrawal from Afghanistan and its consequences in the country and internationally. Koenders draws on his experience working both on the ground in Afghanistan and in his home country of The Netherlands, where he served as foreign minister, development minister, and member of parliament.

Koenders begins his remarks by stating that while the US withdrawal from Afghanistan was clearly a pivotal moment for the country and the region, it will prove to be of lesser importance for the US and Europe going forward. The reality, for Koenders, is that the west has not put enough emphasis on development Afghanistan for the last several years, and that the situation on the ground in Afghanistan will not play a pivotal role in western foreign policy going forward.

He continues with the general assertion that if, after a twenty-year intervention in a country, the same government is still in power, the intervention was a clear failure. In answering the first student question, Koenders notes three failures of the intervention in Afghanistan: 1) excluding the Taliban and other local officials from peace negotiations, 2) conducting the war in Iraq at the same time as the intervention, and 3) focusing too strictly on anti-terrorism rather than economic and social development. He underlines the importance of listening to the people who live in the place where you're intervening, saying that his contacts with civil servants and civil society in Afghanistan, and those in the diaspora, were critical to his work.

Onto the question of the US withdrawal itself, Koenders explains that while he understands President Biden's reasoning, a complete withdrawal at the time it occurred was not wholly necessary. Firstly, he states that the US's deal with the Taliban (made during the Trump administration) could have been adjusted without any undue escalation. More broadly, he contends that western forces did not have to leave at all and could have continued to manage the situation on the ground in Afghanistan.

Turning to the prospects of the Afghan people, Koenders is asked what the international community plans to do going forward regarding the humanitarian concerns in the country, including migration, terrorism, and human rights. Here Koenders emphasizes the necessity to protect the social and economic gains made in the country over the last twenty years. While the west has significantly less power in the country now, engaging with Taliban under some conditionality agreements will be key if there is any hope of securing gains in women's rights, economic growth, and conflict prevention.

Finally, Koenders explains that the manner of the US withdrawal added momentum to the push for European strategic autonomy. He notes that volatility in American foreign policy forces Europe to consider building its own strategic culture, and reconsider the balance of burden, and control, within the transatlantic relationship going forward.

Full Audio:

Withdrawal from Afghanistan: Causes and Consequences

hosted by Professor Michael G. Plummer

Albert Gerard (Bert) Koenders
Former Minister of Foreign Affairs and Special Envoy of the Worldbank on Fragility, The Netherlands

Albert (Bert) Gerard Koenders is Professor of Peace, Security and Justice at the University of Leiden, where he holds the Kooijmans Chair. He is currently Special Envoy on Fragility for the World Bank, serves on the Board of the International Crisis Group, and is Commissioner of the International Commission on Missing Persons.

From October 2014 to October 2017 Koenders was the Netherlands' Minister of Foreign Affairs, during which time (first half of 2016) the Netherlands held the Presidency of the Council of the European Union. Koenders' previous appointments include: Under-Secretary-General of the United Nations; head of the Multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in Mali (MINUSMA); Secretary-General's Special Representative and Head of the UN Operations in Ivory Coast; negotiator and Co-chair for the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development's Busan Partnership agreement and Minister for Development Cooperation, managing a complex development budget of 5 billion euro. Koenders also sat on the Development Committee of the World Bank. He has worked as Director for the organisation Parliamentarians for Global Action, was a member of the parliamentary inquiry committee on Srebrenica, President of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly from 2006 to 2007, and was Founder of the Parliamentary Network on the World Bank and International Monetary Fund, serving as its chair between 2000 and 2007.

From 2000 to 2002, Koenders was visiting professor of Conflict Management at Johns Hopkins University (SAIS) in Bologna.

Koenders studied Political and Social Sciences, International Economics and African Studies at the Free University of Amsterdam and Johns Hopkins University SAIS.
Upcoming Events

Recent Events
Libya and the Ongoing Battle for Legitimacy
Nov 22
Claudia Gazzini
International Crisis Group, Libya
SAIS Perspectives 2021-22 Bologna Launch Event - Disparity in Development
Nov 18
Jyotsna (Jo) Puri
International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD)
Withdrawal from Afghanistan: Causes and Consequences
Nov 08
Albert Gerard (Bert) Koenders
Former Minister of Foreign Affairs and Special Envoy of the Worldbank on Fragility, The Netherlands
Democratic Recession in Central Europe: Causes and Prospects
Nov 04
Adéla Gjuricová
Academy of Science of the Czech Republic
Private Law and the Making of Human Rights
Nov 01
León Castellanos-Jankiewicz
Asser Institute; Netherlands Network for Human Rights Research
How Does Trade Impact Women and How Can Trade Policies Support Women's Economic Empowerment?
Oct 28
Jane Korinek
Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), France

About BIPR
Research Affiliation
Funded Projects
Follow BIPR

© BIPR, all rights reserved - Bologna Institute for Policy Research - via Andreatta 3, 40126, Bologna, Italy