In The News
Explore SAIS
In The News
Explore SAIS

The B.I.P.R. site uses cookies and similar technologies.
By clicking the "Accept" button, or continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, including our cookie policy.


BIPR | SAIS Europe Faculty Panel - America and the World after January 6, 2021
SAIS Europe Faculty Panel - America and the World after January 6, 2021

February 8, 2021 - 18:30

Online Event

Raffaella Baritono - Justin O. Frosini - John L. Harper - Michael Leigh

Event Recap

Professor John Harper opened the seminar analyzing President Trump’s rise to power in 2016, identifying it as a revolt by the perceived victims of globalization and the role of the USA as liberal hegemon and policeman. Harper also emphasized that a form of “white backlash” was also a factor, and that Trump was a symptom and beneficiary of rather than the cause of fear and resentment on the part of many rural, Christian nationalist, and working-class white Americans towards changes in American society. On the impact of the Trump Presidency, and the future in light of November 3 and January 6, Harper offered two alternative perspectives: the past four years may have laid the groundwork for future Republican successes as many of Trump's 74 million voters believe he has delivered on key promises. On the other hand, Democrats now have the opportunity to address some of the social and and economic issues that led to Trump's rise. The Republican Party faces in intractable dilemma because although Trump is still powerful and popular, he is morally compromised and as a leader will be a millstone dragging the party down.

Continuing the analysis of President Trump’s impact, Professor Raffaella Baritono argued that, while polarization and the delegitimization of political opponents have always been a part of the American political system, these practices have historically ended at the end of the campaign cycle. The degree to which President Trump has considered himself above US institutions, feeling only beholden to ‘his’ people, is unprecedented. She stressed that Biden will have to bring back respect and dignity to the procedures of American democracy. Vice President Kamala Harris may play an important role in this as a link between the White House and a deeply divided Congress.

Professor Justin Frosini shed light on the constitutional angle of the 2020 elections and the events that followed, arguing that the transition period (imposed by the Constitution) had an adverse effect on the credibility of American institutions. Furthermore, he warned that with upcoming redistricting, Republicans might engage in further gerrymandering. Finally, he underscored that a significant obstacle to efforts to prevent this is Article V of the US, which sets a high bar to passing constitutional amendments. Indeed, while there have been efforts to circumvent such barriers through inter-state cooperation, such as the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, Professor Frosini highlighted that such initiatives are not likely to be successful. He also pointed out that one should not forget that abolishing the Electoral College would fundamentally alter the federal nature of the US.

Professor Michael Leigh touched on transatlantic relations following President Biden’s election, highlighting a broadly shared sense of relief in European capitals. However, despite the like-mindedness of Biden and many European leaders, Leigh noted that key differences remain. How Europe situates itself between the US and China will be of great importance in coming years. Leigh drew attention to the fact that the German Presidency decided to push the EU to sign the investment treaty with China before the inauguration of the new administration, and without consultation with the US. This was perceived by some in the new US administration as a slap to the face.

Full Audio:

SAIS Europe Faculty Panel - America and the World after January 6, 2021
American Foreign Policy Series

hosted by Professor John L. Harper

Raffaella Baritono
Full Professor of U.S. History, School of Political Science, University of Bologna
Justin O. Frosini
Adjunct Professor of Constitutional Law, Johns Hopkins University SAIS Europe; Director of the Center for Constitutional Studies and Democratic Development
John L. Harper
Chair: Senior Adjunct Professor of American Foreign Policy and Professor Emeritus, Johns Hopkins University
Michael Leigh
Academic Director, Master of Arts in European Public Policy; Senior Adjunct Professor of European and Eurasian Studies, Johns Hopkins University SAIS Europe; Senior Fellow, Bruegel, Belgium

Supported by the Associazione di cultura e di studio italo-americana Luciano Finelli Friends of the Johns Hopkins University.
Upcoming Events
A Dialogue between Dutch Former Minister of Foreign Affairs Albert Gerard (Bert) Koenders and SAIS Europe Students
Mar 08
Albert Gerard (Bert) Koenders
Former Minister of Foreign Affairs and Special Envoy of the Worldbank on Fragility, The Netherlands
Illiberal Democracy or Populist Authoritarianism? The Case Studies of Poland and Hungary
Mar 18
Wojciech Sadurski
University of Sydney; University of Warsaw, Poland
The Global New Deal: Lessons and Legacies
Mar 25
Kiran Klaus Patel
Ludwig Maximilian University Munich, Germany

Recent Events
Decolonizing Politics
Mar 04
Robbie Shilliam
Zanvyl Krieger School of Arts & Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, US
War-Torn: the Unmaking of Syria (2011-2021)
Mar 01
Leila Vignal
University of Rennes-2, France
JHU SAIS Europe 66th Anniversary - America is Woke: Can the Biden Administration Keep Us That Way?
Feb 22
Ambassador Gina Abercrombie-Winstanley
Former US Ambassador to Malta and Former Adviser to the Commander of U.S. Cyber Forces
Why Americans Loved Mussolini
Feb 15
Katy Hull
University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands

About BIPR
Research Affiliation
Funded Projects
Follow BIPR

© BIPR, all rights reserved - Bologna Institute for Policy Research - via Andreatta 3, 40126, Bologna, Italy