In The News
Explore SAIS
In The News
Explore SAIS

The B.I.P.R. site uses cookies and similar technologies.
By clicking the "Accept" button, or continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, including our cookie policy.


BIPR | Autocracy at War: Merit vs. Loyalty in the Red Army during WWII
Autocracy at War: Merit vs. Loyalty in the Red Army during WWII

October 4, 2021 - 18:30

Eugene Finkel, Johns Hopkins University SAIS Europe

Event Recap

For autocratic leaders fighting to stay in power, the struggle of how to promote subordinates while achieving the regime's policy goals looms large. Leaders, unable to carry out all policy measures themselves, promote agents within their regime. However, this is a daunting task when entrusting the wrong person, who could lead to regime overthrow. Coming from the intersection of history and political science, Prof. Eugene Finkel spoke to SAIS on October 4th about his joint research with Prof. David Szakonyi (George Washington University) on how the Red Army tackled this challenge during World War II.

For this case, Finkel and Szakonyi take a different approach by focusing on the under-researched topic of how regimes promote actors in the lower levels of the state apparatus. Filling this gap in scholarship, Finkel and Szakonyi study how the Red Army during World War II approached the task of promotions by focusing on the most elite category of soldiers, fighter pilots. These were highly visible and prestigious members of the Red Army with clear performance indicators, i.e., the number of planes a pilot has downed. Using Russian Ministry of Defense documents and an encyclopedia on the Red Army's most successful fighter pilots, Finkel and Szakonyi analyzed how these pilots were evaluated and promoted.

Within their research, Finkel and Szakonyi defines promotions as discretionary awards for which pilots had to be nominated by their commanders. As these awards were cheap, widely available, and often had huge positive effects for individual and organizational performance, they were frequently used by the regime, giving Finkel and Szakonyi a dataset of 10,000 awards for almost 3,000 pilots. The awards were assessed at the nomination level and the second approval where higher-ups could either upgrade, downgrade, or approve submitted nominations. Additionally, the prestige of the awards was assessed at both levels along with any changes a higher-up made to the award's prestige. Finkel and Szakonyi also coded for pilot characteristics such as party membership, ethnicity, experience, leadership, and bravery (if the pilot had been wounded) and for the pilot's combat situation to see how these factors affected the likelihood of promotion.

Finkel and Szakonyi find that the Red Army's promotional system was a bounded meritocracy, with performance being the key factor of promotion. While party membership played no role, the role of ethnicity was significant at each level. At the nomination level, preference was given to in-groups (ethnic Slavs). Finkel argues this is a result of both prejudice against minority pilots and commanders' increased abilities to understand Russian pilots and feel secure about assuming the risks of nominating them. Conversely, at the second level, higher-ups were more likely to upgrade the awards of minority pilots as they could use these new heroes to inspire higher levels of military consignment among other minorities.

Overall, Prof. Finkel contends that non-democratic leaders are well aware of their main power constraints at all levels of the apparatus and that they are creative about overcoming these problems. He explains that identifying these mechanisms and the reasoning behind promotions helps us understand where future leaders originate from in autocratic regimes.

Full Audio:

Autocracy at War: Merit vs. Loyalty in the Red Army during WWII

hosted by Professor Michael G. Plummer

Eugene Finkel
Johns Hopkins University SAIS Europe

Eugene (Evgeny) Finkel is Associate Professor at SAIS Europe.

Finkel works at the intersection of political science and history and strives to promote a better dialogue between the two disciplines. He was born in Ukraine and grew up in Israel. He received a BA in Political Science and International Relations at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and a PhD in Political Science at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. His research focuses on how institutions and individuals respond to extreme situations: violence, state collapse, and rapid change.

Finkel is the author of Ordinary Jews: Choice and Survival during the Holocaust (Princeton University Press, 2017) and, together with Scott Gehlbach, Reform and Rebellion in Weak States (Cambridge University Press, 2019). His articles have appeared in the American Political Science Review, Journal of Politics, Comparative Political Studies, Comparative Politics, East European Politics and Societies, Slavic Review, Democratization, and several other journals and edited volumes.
Upcoming Events
New Challenges to Transatlantic and European Security
Feb 07
Antonio Missiroli
University of Leiden; NATO's Defense College in Rome; Sciences Po Paris
The Balkans and the Great Powers
Feb 10
Vuk Jeremic
Center for International Relations and Sustainable Development (CIRSD), Serbia
Transatlantic Relations: What Can We Learn from History?
Feb 14
Alessandra Bitumi
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, The Netherland
"The Week that Changed the World": A Panel Discussion to Mark the 50th Anniversary of Nixon's Trip to China
Feb 17
Raffaella Baritono
Chair: Professor of American History, University of Bologna, Italy

Recent Events
The Jihadi Battle for Hearts and Minds: A View from the Ground
Jan 27
Elisabeth Kendall
Pembroke College, Oxford University, UK
Europe's Challenges in the Wider Indo-Pacific
Dec 06
Paola Pampaloni
European External Action Service, Brussels
Libya and the Ongoing Battle for Legitimacy
Nov 22
Claudia Gazzini
International Crisis Group, Libya

About BIPR
Research Affiliation
Funded Projects
Follow BIPR

© BIPR, all rights reserved - Bologna Institute for Policy Research - via Andreatta 3, 40126, Bologna, Italy